I reckon Pomemax hit the nail on the head.
?? using a hand (pistol drill) on slow speed.
In a case like this the hand drill on low ,,,,,, is still too fast.
A pedestal drill would be far better, and can achieve much lower speeds. Your pressure ridges are a classic sign of "speed too high"
I don't know how you went about it,, but if I were making these I would do the counter sink drilling (any drilling) first and foremost (in the plate) then,
cut out your washer shape/outline last.
I do not fear death itself... Only its inopportune timing!
And,,,,It's been proven,,,,, the most trustworthy females in my entire life were all canines.