APS450 vs 650 for 9mm - big difference?

Reloading equipment, methods, load data, powder and projectile information.

APS450 vs 650 for 9mm - big difference?

Post by Yes » 20 Nov 2026, 3:31 pm

As per the title... I want to reload 12g and 9mm, and thinking about stocking up on the one powder to do it all. I would like the slower burning 450 for my 12g lighter loads (lower recoil for the missus). For 9mm, at this stage using I've been using 124 Berry's. Tigershark guy did a review on the 450 before the 650 came out and rated it higher than AP70 (which is what I used for years!). The gun is Gen 5 Glock. And will be a Gen 6 glock once they arrive in Aus in the 49A varient.

Any real world experience on the forum? Or should I just go 450 for the 12g and 650 for the 9mm?
Yes
Private
Private
 
Posts: 84
New South Wales

Re: APS450 vs 650 for 9mm - big difference?

Post by morerams » 20 Nov 2026, 8:42 pm

I wouldn't be too set on using one powder, supply is inconsistent at best.
morerams
Recruit
Recruit
 
Posts: 35
Queensland

Re: APS450 vs 650 for 9mm - big difference?

Post by deye243 » 20 Nov 2026, 9:55 pm

The 450 is faster than 650 as it's the powder that replaces ap50 and 650 replaces ap70 .
I use aps650 in 9mm and find it very clean and consistent with plated hardcast .
If you are after shot shell loads for hunting i would use 650 but if its just clays then 450 or 350 if you can find some .
User avatar
deye243
Major
Major
 
Posts: 2839
Victoria

Re: APS450 vs 650 for 9mm - big difference?

Post by bladeracer » 21 Nov 2026, 8:04 am

morerams wrote:I wouldn't be too set on using one powder, supply is inconsistent at best.


If you buy plenty of it supply becomes a non-issue, at least not for many years.

Being able to use one powder is useful, but it may be less than optimal in some chamberings. Pistol and shotshell powders are essentially the same thing so almost any pistol/shotshell powder would work fine in most of your pistol and shotshell loads, and would probably work in low-velocity rifle loads for many rifle chamberings. I don't chase velocities and don't load anything even as hot as factory loads so I don't need "optimal" powders. I just need a powder that makes a bang and gives reliable ignition with consistent accuracy.

I use AR2206H in all my rifle loads, from .204 to 8x57mm, and I was using AS50N for 12 gauge and all my pistol loads from .38 Special to .45ACP and .44-40. Buy a few 4kg bottles of each and you'll probably have enough to see your life out, for most people.

I have tested AR2206H in .38 Special and 9mm, it does work, but velocities are low and it wouldn't run my Hi Power. I'll test it in .44-40 and .45ACP some day as well.
Practice Strict Gun Control - Precision Counts!
User avatar
bladeracer
Field Marshal
Field Marshal
 
Posts: 14029
Victoria

Re: APS450 vs 650 for 9mm - big difference?

Post by Yes » 21 Nov 2026, 8:57 am

Thanks for the replies.
As blade racer notes, if like to buy enough that will see me through another covid or whatever comes next. Might grab 450/650 and tinker with both, knowing I can use both in 12g/9mm either way.
Yes
Private
Private
 
Posts: 84
New South Wales


Back to top
 
Return to Reloading ammunition