animalpest wrote:So section 11A requires a written letter for land to hunt and shoot on.
I presume the Police have considered the safety aspects of various calibres relative to that land. I guess you would need to demonstrate that a calibre is safe if you don't agree with the coppers opinion?
So that is genuine reason. What about genuine need?
And it doesn't say it must be a primary producer, just "land".
animalpest wrote:Most every person who "enforces" a law makes decisions but rarely are they "arbitrary" (i.e.based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system).Whether to caution, prosecute and so forth. Most need to send it upstairs but Police officers can make judgement calls on that.
In interpreting and applying the law, every agency has policies on these. I guess that is what you need to fight.
Diamond Jim wrote:bladeracer wrote:N.Field wrote:Some WA dealers offer property letters at a cost of around $200. Does anyone know if these things are usually accepted by WAPOL and whether they ever follow up to confirm that the licensee actually shoots on the property specified in the letter?
I thought they were closer to $300, despite not allowing you to actually shoot on the property.
I've heard that Police do follow up, but I don't have first-hand experience of such.
Probably a question better asked of the dealer selling it, and also worth making a call to the property owner.
You could try getting a NSW R-licence or a Victorian game licence and tell them you travel to hunt over here? Being WA though, I'd be very impressed if they considered that to be reasonable.
I can tell you WAPOL definitely do (sometimes) follow up. I submitted a letter from my brother-in-law who runs 18,000+ acres and the local police asked him about my bone-fides when they crossed him in the street. Very low-key, like do you know this bloke? What's the connection? That sort of level.
ZaineB wrote:animalpest wrote:Most every person who "enforces" a law makes decisions but rarely are they "arbitrary" (i.e.based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system).Whether to caution, prosecute and so forth. Most need to send it upstairs but Police officers can make judgement calls on that.
In interpreting and applying the law, every agency has policies on these. I guess that is what you need to fight.
youre partially correct, however what they are doing is enforcing things that are not legislated. this is literally the equivalent of charging you with drug possession for having panadol or booking you for speeding for going 90kmh in a 110kmh zone.
Faedy wrote:So what properties/ stations are still giving out letters that satisfy the popo?
Faedy wrote:So what properties/ stations are still giving out letters that satisfy the popo?
Barbarian wrote:Just spoke to the clerk at my LGS, apparently the reason for Kalbarri SA letters being knocked back is “in the interests of public safety” and they were told it was the sheer number of letters being used for the given property size.
Ella Valla’s letters are still good.
bladeracer wrote:Is there an actual law that makes it illegal for ten thousand shooters to use one property if they choose too?
deye243 wrote:I still scratch my f****** head and ask myself why any so-called free Australian would live in a state like Western Australia should be torn off the country and pushed all the way to fukin Africa
Barbarian wrote:deye243 wrote:I still scratch my f****** head and ask myself why any so-called free Australian would live in a state like Western Australia should be torn off the country and pushed all the way to fukin Africa
Though the future of shooting in WA might be uncertain given the state Gov't shafting us with the current Firearms Ammendment Bill
I've been shooting in WA since I could legally get my firearms license and even before that with my old man.
WA Might be the worst state in terms of applying the dreaded Appearance Laws but there are other things going for the state.
Cat C for IPSC/Clay Target
No license or membership duration required for Collectors License for Cat A/B/C/H(Pre 1946)
Fully legal for unlicensed persons and minors to shoot the Licensee's firearms under direct supervision (something that is a violation in some jurisdicitions)
No Mag Limit on Cat A/B (Though WAPOL don't like ar16/m16 mags, once your licensed you can get whatever)
We have to deal with high license fees and no PTA system but moving out of state isn't a form of protest, its capitulation.
bladeracer wrote:
Victoria has CatC for clay competition but only on a medical certificate.
In WA you can't actually use your firearms held on a Collector's Licence, here we can at least use them at club events. We can also transfer them to our CatA/B licences, for the $10 cost of a PtA, and take them hunting if we want to, or to our CatH licence and shoot some competitions.
Mag limits are way over-emphasised I think. I had big mags for my 10/22 when I was a kid and rarely used them, too heavy and bulky to carry in the field, too damned fiddly to load them fully. Much better to just carry five 10rd mags. I have 25rd .22LR mags that are restricted to 10rd and 15rd, trying to load fifteen rounds is sufficient to remind me how painful loading the 25rd mags were. In CatB I don't think most shooters have any interest in loading 30rd mags for hunting purposes, they're really just useful for doing mag dumps for fun, and perhaps IPSC competition. I'd rather carry some 10rd mags (my hunting rifles use AICS 10rd mags).
I can't recall if WA is one of the states that regulates barrels, can I have a selection of different barrels for a shotgun for example or do you need a permit there for each barrel?
I would suggest that if everybody left WA, the government there can implode trying to regulate itself, and then free people can go back and return it to the state it used to be.
N.Field wrote:Some WA dealers offer property letters at a cost of around $200. Does anyone know if these things are usually accepted by WAPOL and whether they ever follow up to confirm that the licensee actually shoots on the property specified in the letter?
Barbarian wrote:bladeracer wrote:
Victoria has CatC for clay competition but only on a medical certificate.
In WA you can't actually use your firearms held on a Collector's Licence, here we can at least use them at club events. We can also transfer them to our CatA/B licences, for the $10 cost of a PtA, and take them hunting if we want to, or to our CatH licence and shoot some competitions.
Mag limits are way over-emphasised I think. I had big mags for my 10/22 when I was a kid and rarely used them, too heavy and bulky to carry in the field, too damned fiddly to load them fully. Much better to just carry five 10rd mags. I have 25rd .22LR mags that are restricted to 10rd and 15rd, trying to load fifteen rounds is sufficient to remind me how painful loading the 25rd mags were. In CatB I don't think most shooters have any interest in loading 30rd mags for hunting purposes, they're really just useful for doing mag dumps for fun, and perhaps IPSC competition. I'd rather carry some 10rd mags (my hunting rifles use AICS 10rd mags).
I can't recall if WA is one of the states that regulates barrels, can I have a selection of different barrels for a shotgun for example or do you need a permit there for each barrel?
I would suggest that if everybody left WA, the government there can implode trying to regulate itself, and then free people can go back and return it to the state it used to be.
I shoot my Benelli m4 at IPSC whenever possible, its one reason I'd never consider leaving the state.
We can shoot collector's firearms at approved events, used to be fairly regular that the WAAAS Held shoots but there was some semi-recent issues with the Comissioner's approval - thats in the process of being resolved.
Mag limits matter to me when I'm shooting a PRS match. Being able to run a MDT double stack round with an extended baseplate for 16-17 rounds total. Or a
Yeah barrels are licensed separately, I just bought another shotgun when I wanted something longer.
Fee's suck, thats been a trend in WA forever.
I'm not having a go at you directly Blade, Moving interstate just isn't a practical solution for allot of people. Also as I collect combat shotguns, getting to shoot the crown jewel of my collection regularly on the clock is great, Something I can't do in most other states.
bladeracer wrote:That's news to me, I'm sure the WA Firearms Act states pretty succinctly that firearms held on a Collector's licence can never be fired, I'll have to read it again when I have a chance. here there are a lot of Collector club events so we could pretty well shoot most of our Collector firearms fairly regularly, assuming you're content to use them only at clubs and ranges, that does nothing for me so I wouldn't be.
I understand about moving, shooting has to be a very important part of your life, but it is for me (I have spent twice the amount on firearms since moving here than it cost to buy my house and land in Perth in 1994), which is why Victoria is _so_ much better. WA has tons of money though, roads are much better, infrastructure is better, life is easier, the standard of living is better, work is plentiful, and incomes are higher (and there are less smokers!). It has a lot going for it, if you're willing to let the government dictate what you can do. I would much rather be free to grab a rifle out of my reasonably extensive collection and head for the bush (public land here is still free for the use of the public) whenever the impulse takes me, than be free to use a Benelli at club events when somebody else schedules it. But, I grew up with semi-auto rifles/guns and pump guns, so they don't have any novelty value to me. I can understand why some younger people are willing to let the government allow them to use them under very restricted circumstances. Personally, I would prefer IPSC adapt to using firearms that are readily available in our environment, it is supposed to be _practical_ competition after all. IPSC is the most fun you can have with handguns though, did it for 13 years in Perth.
Barbarian wrote:It does, you are not mistaken - the WAAAS was operating under a letter from the commissioner for it's club events - while the WAAAS wasn't found in infringement of the act a couple of years ago, they had to stop till the approval was sorted out and the matter is still ongoing.
Larry wrote:Its such a stupid system as the letter really gives you no rights at all. Its not like you can just turn up to the property as if it was yours and go shooting. You still have to get prior permission to turn up and shoot.
Its really only a letter that says that this property owner may let you come and shoot. As in the property owner allows shooting on his property.
They should be done away with the police should be more worried about the scams going on with large numbers of property letters being sold without the property owners even having knowledge of who it is going to and making money from it.
bladeracer wrote:Barbarian wrote:It does, you are not mistaken - the WAAAS was operating under a letter from the commissioner for it's club events - while the WAAAS wasn't found in infringement of the act a couple of years ago, they had to stop till the approval was sorted out and the matter is still ongoing.
Are you saying that you actually can't use your Collector licence firearms for IPSC after all?
Barbarian wrote:deye243 wrote:I still scratch my f****** head and ask myself why any so-called free Australian would live in a state like Western Australia should be torn off the country and pushed all the way to fukin Africa
Though the future of shooting in WA might be uncertain given the state Gov't shafting us with the current Firearms Ammendment Bill
I've been shooting in WA since I could legally get my firearms license and even before that with my old man.
WA Might be the worst state in terms of applying the dreaded Appearance Laws but there are other things going for the state.
Cat C for IPSC/Clay Target
No license or membership duration required for Collectors License for Cat A/B/C/H(Pre 1946)
Fully legal for unlicensed persons and minors to shoot the Licensee's firearms under direct supervision (something that is a violation in some jurisdicitions)
No Mag Limit on Cat A/B (Though WAPOL don't like ar16/m16 mags, once your licensed you can get whatever)
We have to deal with high license fees and no PTA system but moving out of state isn't a form of protest, its capitulation.
dnedative wrote:NSW government figured it out because they could make an earn off it, you dont need a property letter here, just go get a game hunting license off the government which will support a firearms license and and you can actually go hunt on public land all over the state.
bladeracer wrote:dnedative wrote:NSW government figured it out because they could make an earn off it, you dont need a property letter here, just go get a game hunting license off the government which will support a firearms license and and you can actually go hunt on public land all over the state.
In NSW you also need an R-Licence, or a G-Licence for certain hunting on private property.