happyhunter wrote:<<Genesis93>> wrote:Bit dramatic with the comparo.... 308win at 1000yds would have a fraction of the energy of the 357Mag at muzzle..... but I get the point, a decent rifle round compared to a handgun round, accuracy and range, but a rifle against four black landcruisers and an APC full of M4s and MP5s..... no wonder these guys are bolting across states
The comparison isn't mine. Somebody
that knows better than you or me said it and the data doesn't lie.
24" barrel 1:12 twist shooting M118LR (Federal GMM, 175g SMKs) at 1000 yards = 547 ft-lbs -- vs -- 4" barrel 158g .357 Mag Federal DoubleTap JHPs = 539 ft-lb at the muzzle. You can check that for yourself.
I have no idea how proficient these two pricks are with a rifle although no doubt their number is going to come up.
How do you know they know better then me? did he/or she tell you so??
The beauty about numbers, is just that, they're just numbers, random assortments at times, that can be assembled in various orders to 'prove' anything statement... from numerous combinations of loads.... so choose a load, a projectile and their are limitless combinations, if you want to 'prove' how dangerous the 308win is then a statement will convince the 'majority'.....and make good reading for the masses -
Yes, the media AKA the presstitutes HAVE taken quotes
from the forums....so just imagine;
"Fugitive's rifle(s) more powerful at one kilometer (
yards is too difficult) than Dirt Harry's hand cannon (
or insert other more scary description) at point blank (
they always use the 'point blank' without an understanding of the words).... then for good measure they might even mention that its a common type of rifle....
.....but as far as this particular comparison, I selected the hottest pistol load - which makes sense if your comparing the max energy
357Magnum,125gr@1839fps.... I then spoke some reverse Polski to the HP and came up 939 ft.lb Energy at the muzzle.....even the 158 produces 800+ft.lb according to ADI velocities...and these are not even rifle loads.... (so if you want to prove how powerful the 308 is you might even choose lighter or min loads
)
While for the 308win, I selected the most popular projectiles 150, 168 and ultimately came up with maximum retained energy of 333 and 476ft.lb at range....respectively...even the 175gr is less than 500ft.lb...
So, with the correct combination the 357Mag is 2x 308win....given that you could get a few more fps from the 357, while the 308win is pushing it to get that energy with ideal conditions not to mention it's a heck of a good deal easier to get the 357 onto target at the zero feet range compared to the 308 at 1000yds, at least for me.....ABC fact check results are in.
cue; long range keyboard snipers