Maddco Vs Swan

Improving and repairing firearms. Rifle bedding, barrel work, stock replacement and other ways to improve your firearms.

Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Mitch » 14 Mar 2017, 5:19 am

Morning

Just curious peoples opinions on the above barrel brands. Not others.

Who makes the better barrels?

Will be a 6x45 and both maddco or Alan Swan can supply and fit chambered barrel, just unsure which is likely to be more accurate and reliable?

Cheers
Mitch
Lance Corporal
Lance Corporal
 
Posts: 224
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Gamerancher » 14 Mar 2017, 4:21 pm

deleted :oops:
Last edited by Gamerancher on 15 Mar 2017, 9:32 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Gamerancher
Sergeant Major
Sergeant Major
 
Posts: 1596
New South Wales

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Supaduke » 14 Mar 2017, 7:05 pm

Well .. . That certainly shot this thread in the foot (pun intended)
Supaduke
Warrant Officer C2
Warrant Officer C2
 
Posts: 1230
Victoria

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Mitch » 14 Mar 2017, 8:26 pm

Gamerancher wrote:I think you will find that Swan does't actually make barrels.


Well that depends who you talk to? Ive heard both yes and no?

Either way woukd people prefer swan chambered + fitted, or maddco
Mitch
Lance Corporal
Lance Corporal
 
Posts: 224
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by deye243 » 15 Mar 2017, 1:56 am

just look at the gear list at the benchrest event and there is your answer
User avatar
deye243
Second Lieutenant
Second Lieutenant
 
Posts: 2207
Victoria

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by TheDude » 15 Mar 2017, 5:52 am

His website says he does http://www.allanswangunsmithing.com/barrels

No idea on quality compared to maddco
User avatar
TheDude
Corporal
Corporal
 
Posts: 313
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by straightshooter » 15 Mar 2017, 7:24 am

Last time I enquired with Allan Swan, which was a while ago, he was still making barrels but his 5.56 rifling button was broken. At the time he only made .224 and .308 barrels. You may need to determine whether the 6mm barrel is made by him or bought in.

I suspect that the real question the OP is asking is which of the two will provide the better "package" for much the same price.
There is no question that Maddco is capable of delivering the highest quality if the customer is prepared to pay.
Although I have never had any actual dealings with Swan I suspect a buyer who wants a replacement barrel for a minimum outlay will have a better experience dealing with him rather than Maddco.
The OP might care to read my post in a nearby thread regarding TSE barrels.
"Anything is possible if you don't know what you are talking about."
"There is no expedient to which a man will not resort to avoid the real labor of thinking." Sir Joshua Reynolds
straightshooter
Warrant Officer C1
Warrant Officer C1
 
Posts: 1263
New South Wales

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Mitch » 15 Mar 2017, 7:47 am

Money is not the problem.

In fact maddco is only $100 more.

I have heard a few people who have had issues with maddco work. Not necessarily with the barrel.

Swan seems to have an awesome rep hence why they were an alternative
Mitch
Lance Corporal
Lance Corporal
 
Posts: 224
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Tripod » 15 Mar 2017, 8:23 am

Yes Allan Swan does make his own barrels, I find Allan's barrels are perfect for what I do but that isn't benchrest just general shooting and a lot of hunting (And I build a lot of wildcats) I have just ordered a .40cal barrel blank from TSE but only because 40cal is one size that Allan doesn't do but it will be going to Allan for profiling and fitting. I have quite a few of his barrels up to .50cal. I also have a couple of rifles getting done at the moment and I will be dropping a few more rifles in to get done in May when I am up there.
I can tell from the fact he is only $100 cheaper that you want a S/S barrel and yes his S/S barrels are dearer than his Moly barrels.
Tripod
Corporal
Corporal
 
Posts: 269
Tasmania

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Mitch » 15 Mar 2017, 9:00 am

Yea mate staino barrel. Might as well
Mitch
Lance Corporal
Lance Corporal
 
Posts: 224
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Tripod » 15 Mar 2017, 9:21 am

Mitch wrote:Yea mate staino barrel. Might as well

I built my 6x45 with a Moly barrel and still need to finish some load development but it is already shooting extremely well and definitely knocks the ferals flat. I built mine mainly because I have a large amount of 6mm projectiles to use.
Tripod
Corporal
Corporal
 
Posts: 269
Tasmania

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by duncan61 » 15 Mar 2017, 9:47 am

The swan website is cool
.22 winchester .22hornet .222 .243 7mm rem mag cbc 12g
User avatar
duncan61
Officer Cadet
Officer Cadet
 
Posts: 1905
Western Australia

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by deanp100 » 26 Mar 2017, 10:16 pm

AS Tripod said, Allan most definitely makes barrels and very good ones. He makes a lot for bench rest shooters and I have seen a few of them ready to fit on his front counter and they are impressive.
deanp100
Corporal
Corporal
 
Posts: 425
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Smiley » 27 Mar 2017, 8:21 pm

I'll never own another Maddco.
Smiley
Private
Private
 
Posts: 73
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Mitch » 28 Mar 2017, 4:53 am

Why?
Mitch
Lance Corporal
Lance Corporal
 
Posts: 224
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Smiley » 28 Mar 2017, 5:19 am

Mitch wrote:Why?

The short version of the story,
I've had a few after market barrels, the quality of the barrel and service was by far the worst.
Smiley
Private
Private
 
Posts: 73
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Mitch » 28 Mar 2017, 10:39 am

Service seems to be a common complaint with maddco. Quality of their barrels isnt too common, quality of their chambering and fitment does however
Mitch
Lance Corporal
Lance Corporal
 
Posts: 224
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Shanestokes » 07 Feb 2019, 10:16 pm

If got both Maddco and swan barrels
Maddco barrel 375 cal shoots great bug holes at 100 meters all day
Swan barrels 243 ackley best barrel iever owned shoots 1/4 moa all day (if I do my part)
260 ackley shoots 1/2 moa consistently have shot it to 800 meters
Very impressed with swan barrels won’t waste my time going anywhere else
Shanestokes
Recruit
Recruit
 
Posts: 1
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by SCJ429 » 09 Feb 2019, 8:42 am

Smiley wrote:I'll never own another Maddco.


I have had the opposite experience, the best barrel I have ever owned was a Maddco, it shot in the .100 and I have bought Maddco as my first choice. I have seen Maddco barrels win National competitions and been beaten by guys using these barrels. I have never used a Swan barrel but have used Pac Nor, RDT, Hardy, Benchmark and Shillen.
SCJ429
Lieutenant Colonel
Lieutenant Colonel
 
Posts: 3206
New South Wales

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Bill » 09 Feb 2019, 10:20 am

Had a TSE barrel installed by Swan and it shot 3 shot 0.5moa allday

Had TSE put a few of their own barrels on and work was top notch just took a bit longer than I woulda liked

Never bothered with Maddco
When a guy is digging his own grave, you don’t fight him for the shovel.

Success leaves clues, Fools follow failure !

20 Hornet, 218 Bee, 222 Rem, 256 WM, 6mm ARC, 6.5 Grendel, 6.5x55 Scan, 270 Win, 357 Mag, 358 Win, 9.3x62, 500 A Square
User avatar
Bill
Warrant Officer C1
Warrant Officer C1
 
Posts: 1253
New South Wales

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Homer » 12 Feb 2019, 8:31 am

G'Day Fella's,

Mitch, I'm probably biased about this, and I have never owned a Swan barrel.

There is a reason why MADDCO barrels are so difficult to obtain ................ there is a long back log of orders for them.
This is because they are so good (One of the Best barrels made), and everybody wants them.
This leave to door open to others, to fill the void (enter Mr Swan, etc).
Accuracy International made their name using MADDCO barrels, and a whole heap of other people (like myself), have used them for years.

I could go on but I'm sure you get the picture (they are worth the wait!).

Doh!
Homer
Homer
Corporal
Corporal
 
Posts: 340
Australian Capital Territory

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by SCJ429 » 13 Feb 2019, 7:14 pm

What calibers do you chamber your Maddco barrels in Homer and what do you use them for?
SCJ429
Lieutenant Colonel
Lieutenant Colonel
 
Posts: 3206
New South Wales

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by rustypic » 04 Mar 2019, 9:21 pm

Here's my 2 bobs worth. I was quoted $1200 for a Madco barrel and another customer in the shop told me not to touch them, so I did a lot of googling. The result was about 50/50 for Madco, not a bad comment about Swan barrels, in fact a lot of great comments re accuracy and quality, so I went for Swan. I was quoted $650 for a chrome/moly barrel that I requested with no frills, I want to keep the rifle as original as possible. Here's the kicker, they have had the action for just on 5 months and not a single word from them, I have been sending them little reminders but nothing. If I ever get my barrel I will post my findings after I test it but if you want a Swan barrel don't be in a hurry and request a time frame !!!
:? :x
I wondered why the ball was getting bigger. Then it hit me.

22 Win LA
22 Brno Fox K-Hornet
243 Win 70 Featherweight
308 Savage 10/110 Trophy Hunter
Couple of Shotties but miss my 5 shot semi auto :(
User avatar
rustypic
Recruit
Recruit
 
Posts: 22
Victoria

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by SCJ429 » 05 Mar 2019, 8:30 pm

You were quoted $1200 for the barrel? Was that chambered and fitted? My gunsmith charges me under $1000 fitted and takes less than a week once I drop off the rifle.
SCJ429
Lieutenant Colonel
Lieutenant Colonel
 
Posts: 3206
New South Wales

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by bigrich » 06 Mar 2019, 5:00 am

SCJ429 wrote:You were quoted $1200 for the barrel? Was that chambered and fitted? My gunsmith charges me under $1000 fitted and takes less than a week once I drop off the rifle.


If you can get a one week turnaround your very lucky. Trying to get any gunsmith work done around Brisbane is a big lesson in patience. I rang one and was told ring back in three months to see if they could take on my rebarrel job ! I’ve had work done by swan, and yeah, it’s a bit a wait as they are always very busy
User avatar
bigrich
Brigadier
Brigadier
 
Posts: 4483
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by SCJ429 » 06 Mar 2019, 7:02 am

I get that everyone is busy but I cannot be without a rifle for three months. They would just have it sitting around for most of that time. If you have your new barrel and the reamer does it still take months? John Gilles is in Brisbane and his turn around must be better than that. You might have to book months ahead but assuming it is just metalwork the time your rifle is in his shop must only be short.

I give my smith the specs for a new barrel and pay for it, he rings me when the barrel arrives and he has time to fit it. This process may take months. I drop the rifle off with the reamer and pick it up a week later
SCJ429
Lieutenant Colonel
Lieutenant Colonel
 
Posts: 3206
New South Wales

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Sergeant Hartman » 06 Mar 2019, 7:45 am

Was taking to someone about john Giles, he recons it will be a 12 month build for his benchrest rifle.

Maybe gunsmiths should do is take a deposit, and enter your name in the book, when they get say 2 weeks away then ask you to post it down to them. But maybe that will increase the wait times when more.
Sergeant Hartman
Sergeant Major
Sergeant Major
 
Posts: 1722
Victoria

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by bigrich » 06 Mar 2019, 8:05 am

I had a rebarrel done on a model 70 222 done by swan before Christmas. I was told a 6-8 week turnaround, it did take 8 till it was ready for pickup. When there is more involved smithing involved, it can take a lot longer. Allan’s expertise is in demand, especially for older stuff like martini and m17’s and such, so he’s usually got a mountain of work in front of him. He’s over 70, and does well to go at the pace he does. His son grant does the barrel work. This might be more info than is necessary, but I thought I would put the human side of this into perspective for some of you who haven’t had the opportunity to meet and talk with these fellas. Cheers
User avatar
bigrich
Brigadier
Brigadier
 
Posts: 4483
Queensland

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by Sergeant Hartman » 06 Mar 2019, 8:15 am

Mate sorry I wasn't appearing rude, I got a barrel done by Alan and I a.m very happy it shoots like a laser. The blueing matches the gun just perfect. For the price it cost me including shipping you can't even get a maddco barrel let alone fitting.

He has mad skills and reasonably priced, no wonder he's got a wait time.
Sergeant Hartman
Sergeant Major
Sergeant Major
 
Posts: 1722
Victoria

Re: Maddco Vs Swan

Post by bigrich » 06 Mar 2019, 9:18 am

Ziad wrote:Mate sorry I wasn't appearing rude, I got a barrel done by Alan and I a.m very happy it shoots like a laser. The blueing matches the gun just perfect. For the price it cost me including shipping you can't even get a maddco barrel let alone fitting.

He has mad skills and reasonably priced, no wonder he's got a wait time.


All good mate, I didn’t take ya for being rude, I can understand the frustration of waiting, I’ve been in that position a few times. I just wanted to put a human side to what goes on with this particular family business.
User avatar
bigrich
Brigadier
Brigadier
 
Posts: 4483
Queensland

Next

Back to top
 
Return to Gunsmithing