niteowl wrote:Many years ago I believed the the 234 was the perfect all round cartridge. But over the years I found it to be too much for light work and not enough for the heavy work and have gone a different way. Now comes the flood of arguments.
There is no perfect answer and every one will have different opinion as to what to use where. OK ,no problem with that.
YOU and ONLY YOU can decide what YOU want ! !.
I spent most of my younger years; convinced that a .30-30 and a .243 were all I could ever possibly need.
The .243 87gn BTHP Hornadys were particularly nasty on even large pigs, so somewhat overkill for lighter game(but still worked just fine).
At that stage, I thought the .308win as being overkill for pigs.
Circumstances have changed, and also the type of hunting/shooting I'm doing these days, and so I now have a .223 for daily use,
and a .308 for when I expect to meet heavier game.
The .223 mostly runs 75gn pills, and seems to nearly do as good a job on large pigs as the .243 did.
[Much as I love the consistent accuracy of the .243 87gn Vmax, I'm not sure they are as hard-hitting as the older 87gn BTHP's, on larger pigs.]
The .243 gets the occasional run, but isnt my first choice.
This is partly because that particular rifle cant be easily modified to better suit me(Krico M603).
If I didnt already have the .243, I'd consider something like a 6.5CM instead of the .243; preferrably a Tikka, as I have 2 others.
But the cost of changeover is hard to justify, unless the .243 died.
I agree with niteowl; only you can decide what you want..